Chapter 104 Ranch and Rodeo Medicine
For online-only figures, please go to www.expertconsult.com
Ranch Medicine
History and Perspective
For as long as there have been farms and ranches in North America, there have been dedicated, empathetic medical professionals tending to the workers and family members in these rugged environments. Often cited as among the most dangerous professions in the modern age, farming and ranching are synonymous with rural trauma. Rural trauma is a neglected disease of the 21st century.113
In addition to easily identifiable, unique, and statistically evident health care challenges on farms and ranches, more abstract and cultural issues are no less critical. As in most of medicine, the approach to injured ranch workers requires cultural understanding and adjustment, in this case, the European-American culture of rural America.128
Understanding the midwestern U.S. ethos (Figures 104-1 and 104-2) is an important component of the health care provider’s communication skills set. Talking with, not down to, the rural patient is essential. This is especially true for the cowboy, in whom self-respect, individualism, and perseverance in adverse situations are characteristic. In particular, dealing with issues of pain, disability, and loss of autonomy require deference to the cultural milieu. For example, asking a cowboy with a shoulder injury, “Does it hurt?” might not elicit the expected response. However, asking the same cowboy, “Can you use that arm?” will be more likely to elicit congruent dialog.
Epidemiology of Agricultural Disease and Injury
Agriculture ranks among the most hazardous industries in the world. Farmers are at very high risk for suffering fatal and nonfatal injuries, work-related lung diseases, noise-induced hearing loss, skin diseases, and certain cancers associated with chemical use, in addition to repetitive use injuries and prolonged sun exposure. Farming is one of the few industries in which all family members, who often share the work and live on the premises, are at increased risks for injuries, illness, and death.49,90 From 2003 to 2007, deaths occurring in the production of crops and raising of animals in the United States totaled 2334.38 The Census of Fatal Occupational Injuries has reported a death rate of 25.8 per 100,000 workers during a 7-year period, and the Traumatic Injury Surveillance of Farmers in 1993-1995 reported an incidence of nonfatal injuries in the agricultural sector of 7.5 per 100 workers.59 This chapter addresses primarily acute injuries, but a variety of repetitive use injuries are well known to occur in the farm setting. Indeed, farming is a physically arduous occupation that also places workers at risk for such repetitive use injuries as osteoarthritis, neck and lower back disorders, and hand-arm vibration syndromes.142
A variety of acute farmyard injuries secondary to environmental and human factors regularly cause permanent disability and even death. Common injuries include lacerations, amputations, farm animal bites, fractures, and dislocations.11 Raising livestock, heavy equipment, exposure to dust and gas, noise, chemicals and pesticides, and activities that involve heavy lifting are common risk factors for injury on ranches and farms. Certain characteristics surrounding farm-related injuries serve as risk factors and can be used to predict and prevent injuries, so there remains a need for the development and evaluation of injury control interventions.61 Personal contributing factors in most injuries include young age, advanced age, hurried work activities, fatigue, and stress.105 In the older adult rancher, aging and health impairments, such as arthritis and hearing difficulties, are risk factors for falls, for which accommodations and preventive strategies can be employed.127
Eye injuries on the farm are also very common and can be serious. One-quarter of farm-related eye injuries requiring treatment occur during the activity of grinding or cutting metal, resulting in metallic foreign bodies in the eye.127 The largest proportion of eye injuries, however, results from a more diverse set of work activities. The use of appropriate eye protection can prevent the majority of these injuries.
Pediatric Injuries
The discussion of farm injuries includes pediatric injuries, which account for one-fifth of all agricultural injury fatalities and hospitalizations.36 A multitude of hazards to children exist on ranches and farms; 80% of the injured are boys, with many of the injuries being work related.
According to the Census of Fatal Occupational Injuries developed by the Bureau of Labor Statistics, there were 310 work-related deaths to youth less than 20 years of age from 1992 through 2002 in the agriculture production sector, with 15-year-olds having the highest fatality rates.60 Hand injuries in children, often complex and requiring tendon repair, fracture fixation, grafting, and local operative flaps, are well known to occur on farms, most commonly a result of machinery and tractors.130 The most prevalent causes of death in children on the ranch (45% of whom are less than 16 years of age) involve machinery (25%), motor vehicles (17%), and drowning (16%).52 Falls from buildings, haylofts, and horses also account for a significant proportion of these injuries. Approximately one-third of the farm-related pediatric injuries involve head injuries (36.4%), with more than one-half suffering skull fractures.124
Emergency Medical Services and Triage
Identification and Understanding of Illness or Injury
In an emergency, appropriate triage from the ranch environment will enhance survival and minimize morbidity and mortality of the acutely injured patient. Patient outcome is directly related to time from injury to properly delivered definitive care.7 Early recognition of multisystem, life- and/or limb-threatening injuries is necessary before directing the EMS transport system to a particular hospital.
Local Medical Care and Regional Tertiary Care Centers
Understanding the capabilities of nearby hospitals is an essential element in making the right triage decision.7 It is often the case that patients with relatively more complex injuries and illnesses cannot receive definitive medical or surgical care in the rural setting. In many regions, online medical direction and/or standing orders will be available to assist in determining how and where to transport a patient from the ranch setting to the most appropriate medical care facility. Nonetheless, if a patient is unstable, transport to the nearest hospital regardless of specialty care availability might be necessary in order to stabilize the patient before transport to a facility with higher levels of expertise and specialty care.
EMS Activation
In communicating with an online medical control service, the rescuer should provide a concise description of the patient, current set of vital signs, mechanism of injury or medical condition, neurologic findings, and the nearest location where EMS personnel can safely pick up the patient. If time permits, the secondary survey can be communicated to the online medical control officer, but this should not delay initiation of EMS dispatch. Patients with respiratory or hemodynamic instability, decreased level of consciousness, and/or open wounds of the head, neck, chest, or abdomen may require advanced-level treatment in the field or initial evaluation and stabilization at a local emergency department before long-distance travel.113
Unique Injuries and Medical Management
Confined Spaces
Manure pits and silos are dangerous, gas-containing, confined spaces that can generate hazardous levels of hydrogen sulfide and nitrogen dioxide, respectively.122 Methane and carbon dioxide concentrations can also reach toxic levels in manure storage facilities. Simple asphyxiants, such as carbon dioxide and nitrogen, when present in high enough concentrations produce toxicity by lowering the fraction of inspired oxygen (FIO2), placing the exposed individual at risk for hypoxia. Pulmonary irritants represent a large group of noxious agents and produce severe irritation of respiratory tract mucous membranes.95 Clinical presentation of the patient from a confined-space accident often depends upon the type of asphyxiant and severity of exposure.
Simple Asphyxiants (Manure Pits, Grain Bins)
All mammalian life requires oxygen. Normal air is approximately 21% oxygen, 78% nitrogen, and 0.03% carbon dioxide. The human response to lower levels of oxygen includes increased breathing and pulse rate, mild muscular incoordination (12% to 16% oxygen); emotional upset, abnormal fatigue upon exertion, disturbed respiration (10% to 14%); nausea and vomiting, inability to move freely, loss of consciousness, collapse and inability to move or cry out (6% to 10%); seizures, and severe respiratory distress leading to full cardiopulmonary arrest (below 6%).101
Fatalities occur due to asphyxiation or poisoning associated with confined-space manure storage facilities. Manure pits and other confined-space storage structures are characterized by limited openings and ventilation, allowing for buildup of poisonous gases and placing workers at risk for asphyxiation. In one case series of 91 fatalities and 21 severe injuries resulting from livestock manure–related incidents, with over 50% at dairy operations, 21% involved persons under the age of 16 years, with more than one-half occurring to persons conducting repair/maintenance activities on manure-handling equipment or attempting to rescue another person.15
Silos
A silo is a storage structure that holds harvested crops with a moisture content of 50% to 65% for the purpose of fermentation and future use as feed (Figure 104-3, online). Usually the entire plant has been harvested and chopped into segments a few to several inches long before being placed in the storage structure to ferment. The two basic types of silos are upright and trench. Upright, or tower, silos are cylindric structures 20 to 30 feet in diameter and up to 80 feet tall. Forage is unloaded and blown into the silo by specialized equipment. The silage is later unloaded from the silo with another machine that removes the top layer from the silo and blows it down into a wagon or conveyor for delivery to livestock (Figure 104-4, online).
FIGURE 104-4 Silo involved in a fatal explosion incident.
(Courtesy Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.)
Treatment
Fire departments and other emergency responders should be trained to recognize confined-space hazards on farms, understand the associated dangers, know how to test the air quality in a confined space, and have a pressure-demand supplied-air respirator with a long air hose as part of the emergency equipment for silo rescues. For immediately dangerous to life and health (IDLH) atmospheres, this type of respirator must be equipped with a small cylinder of escape air.97
Self-contained breathing apparatus (SCBA) equipment may not be suitable for some silo rescues because the air tank can be too bulky for climbing the silo chute or the outside ladder or for negotiating the inside of the silo. Wearing SCBA equipment is essential for all rescue personnel who enter a manure pit where a victim is lying down. Before entering a manure pit or silo, restoring ventilation to the structure as rapidly as possible enhances the likelihood of safe ingress/egress. Fire departments and other emergency responders should develop and implement a written respiratory protection program that complies with the requirements of Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) standards and General Industry Safety Standard, Part 74, Firefighting.97
Pulmonary Irritants (Manure Pits, Silos, Grain Bins)
When the acid-producing reaction occurs in the upper respiratory tract, there will generally be less alveolar injury but still possibly life-threatening laryngeal edema, or laryngeal spasm and bronchospasm. Agents with less water solubility travel a greater distance into the pulmonary tree before reacting with mucosal water molecules, resulting in delayed (2 to 24 hours) symptoms, and causing greater and more irreversible damage to the alveoli and lung parenchyma. In addition, victims may remain in the toxic environment with ongoing exposure to water-insoluble irritant gases for a longer duration (Figure 104-5).
Silo Filler’s Disease
Clinical Presentation
Examination of the patient with silo filler’s disease may uncover predominately pulmonary abnormalities, such as rales, rhonchi, wheezes, and decreased breath sounds. Hypotension can be a result of nitric oxide formation in the vascular system, which reduces systemic vascular resistance and causes vasodilation.71 Cyanosis indicates either methemoglobinemia or hypoxemia. Hemoptysis indicates severe inflammatory reaction within the respiratory tract. Conjunctival injection (erythema) can be a sign of direct exposure to a highly water-soluble irritant gas.
Differential Diagnosis
With general manifesting symptoms, silo filler’s disease has a broad differential diagnosis that includes asthma, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), farmer’s lung, hantavirus pulmonary syndrome, chemical pneumonitis, smoke inhalation, toxic organic dust syndrome (TODS), miliary tuberculosis, angina pectoris, myocardial infarction, infectious pneumonias of all types, pulmonary embolism, and pulmonary toxicity from a variety of noxious gases (e.g., carbon monoxide, chlorine gas, hydrogen sulfide, carbamate, phosgene, ozone, cyanide, organophosphate, salicylate).71
Prevention
Forced ventilation into confined-space storage facilities can be effective in reducing concentrations of noxious gases to levels safe for human entry.102 Educating agricultural workers about the mechanisms of work-related asphyxia and the symptoms/signs of toxicity will enable earlier recognition of exposure and hopefully allow earlier escape from any exposure (Box 104-1).
BOX 104-1
Safety Tips Regarding Silos, Grain Bins, and Manure Pits
Safety tips regarding silos and grain bins can prevent asphyxiation:147
Silos
Manure Pits
From Youth in Agriculture: Confined spaces, U.S. Department of Agriculture, Occupational Safety and Health Administration. http://www.osha.gov/SLTC/youth/agriculture/confinedspaces.html.
Grain Storage Bin Entrapment
Entrapment in bins containing loose agricultural material, usually corn or other grains, is a well-known cause of serious injury and fatality. More than 200 people have been killed and another 300 injured in the past 30 years because of grain suffocation. High-capacity augers are usually implicated in these accidents (Figure 104-6). Severe entrapment injuries and fatalities can occur when suspended materials or crusted surfaces of stored material suddenly break loose and collapse beneath the worker.96 Crusting at the surface of stored grain is called bridging and is more likely to occur when moist grain is stored, typically in rainy harvest seasons. Moisture collects at the surface of the stacked grain and later dries, forming a crusty surface upon which workers are tempted to walk. Bridged grain is extremely hazardous because it prevents grain flow and hides underlying pockets of air, which allow the surface to collapse (Figure 104-7).
FIGURE 104-7 Diagram: Sketch of silo involved in suffocation incident.
(Courtesy Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.)
Farm workers may also be buried by stored grain when it is emptied from the bottom of the bin. Flowing grain can very quickly pull an adult completely down and into the bin. Once an individual’s knees are covered by flowing grain, it is extremely difficult to get free without assistance.19
In a retrospective study, 16% of grain bin entrapment fatalities were children less than 16 years old, and 77% of fatalities involved the activity of unloading the bin at the time of injury.72 Children should never be allowed in or around a grain bin, even when operation has ceased. Entrance to the grain bin should always be locked securely to prevent children from entering. Injury prevention is key (Box 104-2).
BOX 104-2
Prevention of Grain Bin—Related Injuries
Injury prevention strategies include the following:47
From Farm Safety 4 Just Kids: Grain safety. http://www.fs4jk.org/grain_safety.htm.
Clinical Presentation
A majority of grain bin entrapment injuries occur during the unloading process.72 Suffocation occurs if an individual enters a bin of flowing grain and is pulled under. The victim inhales and swallows so much grain that normal oxygenation cannot occur. Asphyxiation by chest wall restriction is another mechanism of death. If the victim is found before succumbing to hypoxia, there may be a lifesaving opportunity. Safety procedures for all rescue personnel must be followed. Establishing that there are no toxic gases in the storage bin is the first priority upon entering the accident scene.
Farmer’s Lung
Farmer’s lung is a hypersensitivity pneumonitis involving the terminal airways, triggered by exposure to organic dust. Thermophilic Actinomycetes and Aspergillus are the more common antigens responsible for this pulmonary reaction, also known as extrinsic allergic alveolitis.145 Exposure to antigenic organisms in other agricultural occupations can also be responsible for farmer’s lung.
Clinical Presentation
Hypersensitivity pneumonitis can be acute or chronic. The acute form of this disease develops after exposure to high concentrations of contaminated hay or compost. Symptoms of fever, chills, cough, dyspnea, and chest pain usually resolve within 12 to 72 hours if further antigenic exposure is avoided. However, inhalation of very large amounts of the organic antigen can induce acute respiratory failure. The chronic form of this disease is generally a result of repeated exposure to the inciting antigen. Irreversible lung damage can result in chronic dyspnea.145
Toxic Organic Dust Syndrome
TODS, also known as toxic alveolitis or pulmonary mycotoxicosis, is a common respiratory affliction in farmers, with an estimated incidence of 6% to 8%.10 Inhalation of organic dust laden with microorganisms, such as fungal spores, molds, bacteria, and endotoxins, and subsequent inflammation are believed to be the pathogenesis of this disease.141 Pig farmers, particularly those who use wood shavings as bedding in hog barns, are at particular risk.140
Clinical Presentation
TODS is characterized by fever occurring 4 to 12 hours after exposure, along with general weakness, dyspnea, headache, chills, body aches, and cough.92 Physical examination, lung auscultation, and chest radiography are usually normal. Lower respiratory system illness, such as reactive airway symptoms, dyspnea, and chest tightness, are consistent with TODS.
Farm Animals
The mere size difference between large farm animals and people makes working with livestock risky business (Box 104-3). Nearly two-thirds of animal-related fatalities on farms and ranches involve horses.73 Beef cattle farms and dairy operations are ranked third among all farming enterprises in injuries per exposure-hour, with 17% of these injuries involving livestock. From 2003 to 2007, approximately 5% (108) of all farm-related deaths in the United States involved cattle, almost always resulting from blunt force trauma to the head or chest. Circumstances associated with these deaths included working with cattle in enclosed areas (33%), moving or herding cattle (24%), loading (14%), and feeding (14%).38
BOX 104-3
Safety When Working Around Animals
When working around animals it is best to take the following precautions:48
From Farm Safety 4 Just Kids: Livestock safety. http://www.fs4jk.org/livestock_safety.htm.
Bulls cause livestock-related deaths and injuries to farm workers. The risk for injury in terms of exposure-hours is higher than certain other hazards on the farm, such as tractor operation.121 Most of these incidents involve the victim being gored inside the bull holding area (i.e., chute or corral).
Farm Equipment
All-Terrain Vehicles
All-terrain vehicles (ATVs) have become very popular in the United States over the past 30 years. These vehicles are marketed and advertised for off-road travel and used for recreation, competition racing, and as work tools on the ranch. The size, power, and ruggedness of these vehicles make them undeniably useful, but riding ATVs is a high-risk activity and deserves special attention to safety.23,25 One study showed that 35% of ATV crashes occur on farms and ranches.25 The impact force of these vehicles when they roll over leads to severe head, facial, and torso crush injuries, in addition to orthopedic injuries.
During the 1980s, researchers found ATVs to be quite dangerous to operators. In 1988, the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission and the ATV industry agreed to cease manufacturing three-wheeled ATVs, but not four-wheeled ATVs, in a consent decree negotiated in federal district court.137,133 Since that time, only four-wheeled ATVs have been manufactured and sold to consumers; however, a small number of three-wheeled ATVs are still in operation. In the years during this consent decree, U.S. consumers continued to be at great risk for injury while riding ATVs.63,77,80
In 1998, the consent decree expired, and ATV manufacturers began increasing the speed, power, and size of ATVs. In 1998, there were approximately 4 million ATVs in use in the United States,134 and in 2003 there were approximately 7 million.119 Since 2003, the ATV industry has increased production of large-engine ATVs threefold; some ATVs can attain speeds of up to 55 mph and weigh 800 lb. Advertising for these vehicles increased markedly after 1997; concurrently, the Consumer Product Safety Commission reported a significant increase in ATV-related injuries.119,136 The number of injuries and deaths caused by ATV incidents approximately doubled from 1997 to 2001 to over 500 deaths and 110,000 injuries, with children under the age of 16 years being disproportionately injured and killed.136 During the last two decades, approximately 6500 persons have been killed in ATV incidents.68
It is widely accepted among experts that children are in extreme danger when riding ATVs.* Although children less than 16 years of age represent only 14% of all ATV riders, they continue to account for up to 47% of ATV-related injuries.135 The most common types of ATV-related injuries are soft tissue injuries, extremity fractures, and head injuries,28 with 38% of children requiring surgery for their injuries in one study,77 and 69% of children requiring either an orthopedic procedure (40%) or a general surgical procedure (29%).28 Approximately 50% of ATV-injured patients suffer head injuries.3 In children, approximately 25% to 35% of ATV-related injuries involve brain injury and/or spinal cord injury.42,81 In one study, during an 11-year period, 45% of ATV-related fatalities due to central nervous system injuries were in children under 16 years of age.23 In response to these disturbing statistics, professional pediatric and orthopedic organizations have been urging parents not to let children operate four-wheeled ATVs.2,4,5,6
Risk factors associated with ATV morbidity and mortality include lack of ATV safety training, inadequate driver experience, young age, vehicle characteristics, and lack of protective head gear.64,110,111 The risk for ATV-related injury is greatest among children less than 16 years of age, males, riders of three-wheeled ATVs, and inexperienced riders; in addition, the risk for injury increases substantially as the ATV engine size increases (especially for three-wheeled ATVs).111