Perspectives: How to Deal with Fever (38 °C) After Arthroplasty: The Surgeon’s Point of View


Author

No of patients

TKA/THA

Mean age (range)

Fever (% patients)

Mean temperature (range)

% of POD fever

Type of workup

% of positive workup

Notes and conclusions

Shetty (2013)

52 patients

Not reported

66.03 (46–83)

25 (48.1 %)

Not reported

Not reported

Not reported

Not reported

Comparison between Hb drop in fever and no fever groups. No differences

Vijaysegaran (2012)

141 blood cultures in 101 patients

58/41 (primary and revisions) + 2 SA

Not reported

Only patient with fever

38.5 °C (38°–39.9°)

Not reported

141 blood cultures

2 positive (1.4 %)

Only evaluation of blood cultures. Temperature alone is not an indication to perform blood cultures

Athanassious (2011)

341 patients

195/146

Not reported

31 % TKA, 36 % THA

TKA = 38.3 °C

TKA = 50 % POD 1, 37 % POD 2

In all cases of fever, UA

TKA = 11 positive UA (18.3 %), 0 positive CXR (0 %)

Fever most likely in POD 1–2, a UA and UCS may not be necessary in the immediate postoperative period. A CXR may only be necessary if multiple fever

THA = 38.3 °C

THA = 58 % POD 1, 33 % POD 2

In second fever, CXR (28 TKA, 18THA)

THA = 7 positive UA (13.4 %), 2 positive CXR (11.1 %)

Czaplicki (2011)

426 patients

214/212

64.1 (15–94)

TKA = 18 fever (8.4 %), 126 leukocytosis (57.5 %), 13 both (6.1 %)

Not reported

TKA = 9 in POD 2 (50 %)

TKA = 21 additional tests: 8 UA, 6 CXR, 2 blood cultures, 5 other tests

TKA = 6 positive tests (28.6 %), 1 joint infection (0.5 %)

Overall use of testing for fever and leukocytosis without specific physical examination findings is low and should not be performed routinely

THA = 49 fever (23.1 %), 122 leukocytosis (57.5 %), 22 both (10.4 %)
 
THA = 25 in POD 1 (51 %)

THA = 39 additional tests: 15 UA, 13 blood cultures, 4 CXR, 7 other tests

THA = 8 positive tests (20.5 %), 1 joint infection (0.5 %)

Ward (2010)

1,100 patients

562/664 both primary and revisions

55.4 % 51–70 years

161 patients (14.6 %)

Not reported

POD 2–3

69 patients (42.9 %) for a total of 236 diagnostic tests: 71 blood cultures, 59 UA, 49 CXR, 57 other tests

35 positive tests (14.8 %): 23.7 % UA, 5.6 % blood cultures, 2 % CXR

Positive predictor variables are fever after POD 3, multiple days of fever, T max of higher than 39 °C. In the absence of signs and symptoms indicative of pneumonia or septicemia, chest X-Ray and blood cultures are ineffective for fever evaluation

Tai (2009)

186 patients

186 TKA

Not reported

Not reported

37.9 °C

POD 1–2

Not reported

Not reported

Inverse relationship between hemoglobin loss and postoperative temperature

Anderson (2009)

102 sts of blood cultures in 50 patients

39/11 (primary and revisions)

67.3 years

All fever

Not reported

Not reported

All blood cultures

No blood culture is positive

Blood cultures are neither useful nor cost effective in evaluating fever immediately after TJA

Bindelglass (2007)

453 patients

240 TKA, 124 THA, 89 hemiarthroplasty

Not reported

Not reported

Not reported

Not reported

Blood cultures in 40 TKA (16.6 %) and 31 THA (25 %)

2 positive blood cultures (1TKA, 1 THA)

Blood cultures are expensive and do not add relevant information

Ghosh (2006)

170 patients

All TKA

78.5 (47–88)

62/170 (36.5 %)

Not reported

18.2 % in POD1, 16.5 % POD 2

Not reported

4/62 with pyrexia (6.6 %), 14/170 (someone without pyrexia, 8.2 %)

No association between pyrexia and infection, allogenic blood transfusion, hemoglobin loss, use of urinary catheter, rheumatoid arthritis, anesthetic type, and previous pyrexia following TKR. Pyrexia in the first 5 days following TKR is usually a normal physiological response and should not cause undue concern about the presence of infection

Andres (2003)

20 patients (evaluation of the role of cytokines)

All TKA

68.3 ± 8.6

10 patients with fever compared to 10 without

Not reported

POD 1–2

Blood cultures, UA and urine culture, and a CXR in POD 2 in 10 patients (group fever)

1 positive urine culture

Significantly higher levels of drain and serum IL-6 in patients who were febrile than in patients who were afebrile at 24 and 48 h after TKA

Shaw (1999)

200 patients

100/100 (primary and revisions)

Not reported

38/200 temperature greater than 39 °C (19 %)

Not reported

POD 1

133 urine cultures (66.5 %), 17 CXR (8.5 %), 5 blood cultures (2.5 %)

11 positive urine cultures, no CXR, no blood cultures

A workup for sepsis is not indicate without signs or symptoms

Guinn et al (1999)

118 patients

All TKA (141)

Not reported

80/141 TKA (56.7 %)

Not reported

Not reported

Not reported

Not reported

Fever following TKA was common and was not necessarily a contraindication to discharge

Kennedy (1997)

90 patients

All TKA (92)

Not reported

All T > 37 °C, 17 % > 39 °C

Not reported

Not reported

Not reported

No prosthetic infection

Early postoperative pyrexia after arthroplasty is a normal physiological response, and a significant pyrexia can be predicted by a drop in hematocrit and/or after postoperative transfusion


TKA total knee arthroplasty, THA total hip arthroplasty, SA shoulder arthroplasty, POD postoperative day, Hb hemoglobin, UA urinalysis, CXR chest X-ray





25.5 Characteristic of an Infectious Fever


Most of the authors agree that more than 20 % of patients develop fever after joint replacement, but just in a small percentage of them, this is correlated to an infectious process. There are some fever characteristics that are correlated to a higher probability of joint, pulmonary, or urinary infections. Fever that is not associated with other pulmonary or urinary symptoms or with other joint signs of infection is rarely associated with an infectious process. One of the risk factors for septic fever is the postoperative day in which the patient develops it: it has been demonstrated that fever developing on POD 3–4–5 has a higher risk to be correlated with an infectious problem. Besides, the modality of fever is another crucial point: some authors reported that spiked fever and multiple febrile episodes are highly associated with infection (Czaplicki et al. 2011). Table 25.1 reports the papers we extracted the data from.


25.6 Role of the Workup Tests


The evaluation of fever is often expensive, invasive, and painful and disturbs patient during recovery hours (Cremeans-Smith et al. 2006), having a negative effect on it. To evaluate early postoperative fever, blood and urine cultures, white blood cell counts, chest X -ay (CXR), and urinalysis (UA) are often obtained, although there are no source of infection in the 95 % of febrile episodes. Anyway fever remains the main indication for workup in the postoperative period, both in trauma and in elective patients. In a different study that we reported, the conclusions are the same: sepsis workup is unnecessary if the febrile response progressively decreases.


25.6.1 The Role of CRP and ESR Level as Diagnostic Tool


C-reactive protein (CRP) is a phase protein synthesized by hepatocytes. Usually in healthy people, the plasma level is very low and its increase is not specific for infection.

Orthopedic surgeon sometimes uses the CRP measurement as a diagnostic tool for infection and for monitoring the effect of the treatment. Uncomplicated cardiac surgery, abdominal surgery, and uncomplicated total hip arthroplasty could induce a temporary rise in CRP (Larsson et al. 1992). Larsson et al. (1992) reported a CRP increase in all the patients examined, after an elective orthopedic surgery, and this is probably due to the tissue damage. They observed different peak levels probably correlated to the amount of tissue injured but also to the type of tissue being damaged. They also reported that the operation time, gender, age, drug history, anesthetic, and blood transfusion did not significantly influence CRP response.

Some authors (White et al. 1998) reported that CRP levels begin to increase 6 h after the trauma, with a peak level in 48–72 h, with return to normal level within 3–6 weeks in the absence of complications.

Dupont et al. (2008) reported that CRP level changes in three phases: it firstly increases up to a peak (reached at POD 2–3) of seven to 14 times the normal range. After POD 3 the level falls rapidly and then decreases more slowly until the normalization at three or four postoperative week. A CRP value of 25 mg/l at POD 21 has a 100 % specificity regardless of the location of the infection, but low sensitivity (58.3 %). Gomez-Navalon et al. (2000) reported a sensitivity of 63.3 % and a specificity of 80.1 % for CRP and judged alpha-1 antitrypsin to be more reliable, with a sensitivity of 87.5 % and a specificity of 85.8 % in detecting infections.

Okafor and Maclellan (1998) also described the trend of CRP. They reported that CRP rises till a mean value of 0.146 g/dl at POD 2 in the normal group versus 0.2 in the infected group. In the infected group, a persistent elevation on day 7 and day 21 was observed. In the same study, the authors have evaluated also the erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR); usually the variations were significantly different for day 0 versus POD 2 and day 0 versus POD 7, but not for day 0 versus POD 21. In the infected group, the postoperative values of ESR were significantly different from day 0 value, reflecting the persistent inflammatory state. ESR value depends on multifactorial variable, so the reliability is low and high value has to be interpreted with caution. They concluded that CRP shows less variability between patients and consequently is a better indicator of the acute phase response than ESR, which requires a series of values in order to demonstrate a trend.

Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Sep 22, 2016 | Posted by in ANESTHESIA | Comments Off on Perspectives: How to Deal with Fever (38 °C) After Arthroplasty: The Surgeon’s Point of View

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access